Skip to main content

Last week we showed that ChatGPT didn’t cite a single company website when asked for the best contractors in Southwest Florida. The obvious next question: does Google’s own AI pick the same companies? We asked both, on the same day, for the same seven local services. The short version: they agree most of the time, and where they disagree is where a well-reviewed business can get lost.

How we tested

On November 18, 2026, we asked ChatGPT (free version, web search on, a fresh chat each time) for its top five in seven trade-and-city pairs along Florida’s Gulf Coast: HVAC in Sarasota, pest control in Port Charlotte, plumbing in St. Petersburg, electricians in Clearwater, roofing in Bradenton, pool service in Venice and garage door repair in Sarasota. The same day, we asked Google’s AI Mode for the best company in each. One run per question per tool, from one signed-in browser in Florida, so treat these as strong signals, not laws: AI answers shift from day to day and person to person. We’re not naming the businesses that came up; this is about the pattern.

What we found

1. They mostly agree. Of the 35 companies in ChatGPT’s top fives, 26 were also recommended by Google’s AI Mode. For electricians in Clearwater, both tools named the exact same five companies.

2. Great reviews aren’t enough for either one. We tracked 53 Gulf Coast businesses with strong Google ratings that Google’s AI had left out of its recommendations two days earlier. On November 18, ChatGPT put 6 of them in its top five. Google’s AI Mode recommended 2.

3. The disagreements are the opportunity. In roofing, garage doors and pool service, five of those well-reviewed businesses made ChatGPT’s top five but were left out by Google’s AI entirely. One of them was ChatGPT’s #1 pick. Being trusted by one AI and invisible to the other is a fixable gap, not a verdict.

4. They read different things. ChatGPT built its lists from third-party directories and review sites; one ranking site showed up in five of the seven answers. Google’s AI Mode showed every pick as a Google Maps listing, with its star rating and review count front and center. For Google’s AI, your Google Business Profile is the first thing it reads.

5. Review count isn’t the rule. Google’s picks ranged from under 100 reviews to more than 13,000. In roofing, it recommended a company with 81 reviews and passed over a five-star roofer with more than four times as many. When Google’s AI explained its picks, it pointed to specifics: years in business, manufacturer certifications, warranty terms and the kinds of jobs each company handles.

What this means for your business

  1. Treat your Google Business Profile as your AI profile: accurate categories, every service you offer, every area you serve, real photos and current hours.
  2. Ask ChatGPT for “best [your service] in [your city],” note every site it cites, and get listed on those sites with details that match your profile exactly.
  3. Say what makes you different in plain words, the same way everywhere: license, certifications, warranty, years in business, emergency service.
  4. Keep earning reviews that mention the job you did and the city you did it in.
  5. Check both tools every month. Winning one doesn’t mean you’re showing up in the other.

Want to see where you stand in both? Book a free AI Visibility Audit and we’ll show you who ChatGPT and Google’s AI recommend in your trade and city, what they read, and what to fix first.

Research and writing by Brandon Evanich, with AI assistance. Read his personal take: they mostly agreed, except when it mattered. Every finding comes from the test described above.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *