We asked ChatGPT the questions your customers are asking it right now: who are the best HVAC companies, plumbers, roofers and pest control companies in Southwest Florida? Then we looked at where its answers came from. The short version: for “best” questions, ChatGPT did not cite a single company website.
How we tested
On November 18, 2026, we asked ChatGPT (free version, web search on, a fresh chat each time) seven real questions: the top five companies in four trades across Cape Coral, Fort Myers and Naples, one urgent “my AC broke, who do I call today” question, one question about local marketing agencies, and one about our own agency. One run per question, one AI tool, one day, so treat these as strong signals, not laws. We’re not naming the businesses that came up; this is about the pattern, not the winners.
What we found
1. For “best” questions, ChatGPT trusts other people’s lists, not your website. Across the four trade questions, every source it cited was a third-party ranking site, directory or review platform. Not one company website.
2. Being on the right list can beat review count. One plumber with only six Google reviews made the top three, because an independent ranking site listed it first and its state license was on record.
3. Urgent questions flip the rules. When we asked “my AC broke and I need someone today,” ChatGPT switched to company websites and quoted specific promises almost word for word: same-day service guarantees, 24/7 availability, years in business.
4. Licenses show up everywhere. The roofing answer listed a Florida license number for every company, and every answer told the reader to verify the license before hiring.
5. A memorable fact gets you picked. ChatGPT labeled its picks with one-line reasons: veteran-owned, family-owned since the 1990s, best for air quality. Businesses with a clear “thing” got a clear label.
6. Ads have arrived. Sponsored results appeared under three of the seven answers.
A 5-step checklist for service businesses
- Search ChatGPT for “best [your service] in [your city]” and write down every site it cites.
- Get listed, accurately, on those sites and keep your details identical everywhere.
- Put your state license number on your website and Google Business Profile.
- Write one specific, checkable promise on your website, like a same-day guarantee, and keep your hours accurate.
- Keep earning reviews that mention your service and your city.
Update: we ran the same kind of test in Google’s AI Mode. See how ChatGPT and Google’s AI compare.
Want to see what ChatGPT says about your business? Book a free AI Visibility Audit and we’ll show you who it recommends in your trade and city, which sites it reads, and what to fix first.
Research and writing by Brandon Evanich, with AI assistance. Every finding comes from the test described above.
